"You'll be working as a sole trader — you'll need to get an ABN." The phrase sounds technical and reasonable. For many immigrants, there's no easy way to know whether this is normal or problematic. In practice, it's one of the most common forms of sham contracting — and it puts the worker in a position where they bear consequences that should fall on the employer.

The difference between employee and independent contractor

In the Australian system, there are two main types of working arrangements with very different legal consequences:

Employee: protected by the Fair Work Act, receives payslips, entitled to superannuation paid by the employer (12%), penalty rates, paid leave (sick leave, annual leave), and protection against unfair dismissal.

Independent contractor: works under an ABN, is not protected by the Fair Work Act, is responsible for their own tax and super contributions, has no paid leave entitlements, and no right to penalty rates.

The TFN (Tax File Number) is simply a tax identification number — every Australian resident has one. Using a TFN does not define the employment relationship. What defines it is the nature of the relationship between you and the person you work for.

What is sham contracting

Sham contracting occurs when a working relationship that is, in essence, employment is structured as an independent contracting arrangement so the employer can avoid legal obligations.

It is illegal under the Fair Work Act. An employer who engages in sham contracting can be fined up to $93,900 per contravention.

How to know if your situation is employment or contracting

The ATO and Fair Work use a multi-factor test — there is no single rule. The main indicators:

IndicatorPoints to employmentPoints to independent contracting
Control over how work is doneEmployer dictates the methodYou decide how to do it
Tools and equipmentEmployer provides themYou provide your own
Working hoursEmployer sets themYou set your own availability
Do you work for other clients?Exclusive to one employerMultiple clients
Financial riskNo risk — paid even if project goes wrongYou bear the loss if something goes wrong
Can you subcontract?You must do the work yourselfYou can send someone else to do it
Integration into the businessUniform, team meetings, internal trainingYou work externally and deliver results

If most of your indicators point to employment but you are set up under an ABN, you may be in a sham contracting situation.

The real consequences for the worker

Agreeing to work under an ABN when the relationship should be employment has concrete consequences:

No employer superannuation: you are responsible for making your own super contributions — which the employer will not pay. Over one year of work at a $60,000 salary, that's approximately $7,200 you miss out on.

No paid leave: sick leave, annual leave, and public holidays are unpaid. An employee is entitled to 10 days of sick leave and 20 days of annual leave per year — which as an ABN worker, you simply don't have.

No penalty rates: weekends and public holidays are paid the same as regular days.

Individual tax responsibility: you declare all income, calculate tax, pay quarterly PAYG instalments, and handle all your own bookkeeping. Accountant costs included.

No unfair dismissal protection: independent contractor agreements can be terminated without the protections provided by Fair Work.

When an ABN is legitimate

Working under an ABN is not always problematic. It is legitimate when:

  • You have multiple clients and decide when and how you work
  • You provide your own tools and equipment
  • You can subcontract parts of the work
  • The contract has a defined deadline for delivering a result, not set hours on-site
  • Certain professions have an established culture of contracting (e.g., IT, design, consulting)

A carpenter with 5 clients and their own equipment working under an ABN is very different from a cleaner who goes to the same company every day at the same hours, uses the company's supplies, and works alongside other company employees — but has an ABN.

What to do if you are in this situation

Assess your situation against the indicators

Use the table above. If most factors point to employment, your situation may be sham contracting.

Consult an accountant or employment lawyer

Before taking any action, understand the tax and employment implications of your specific situation. Retroactive reclassification has tax consequences that need to be managed carefully.

Document everything

Keep contracts, emails, and communications about hours and tasks. This material documents the true nature of the working relationship.

File a complaint with Fair Work if appropriate

The FWO has authority to investigate sham contracting. A complaint can result in reclassification and back payment of entitlements.

Fair Work — Employee vs contractor

The Fair Work Ombudsman has an online quiz to help determine whether a relationship is employment or contracting, based on the applicable legal factors. Available at fairwork.gov.au/find-help-for/independent-contractors.